Library Banner
Scholarly Journals vs. Popular Magazines

CRITERIA

SCHOLARLY JOURNALS

POPULAR MAGAZINES

         

Definition*

  • Concerned with academic study, especially research
  • Exhibiting the methods and attitudes of a scholar
  • Having the manner and appearance of a scholar
  • Written for the general reader

Appearance

  • Plain cover
  • Plain paper
  • Generally have a sober, serious look
  • Often contain many graphs and charts but few glossy pages or images
  • Eye-catching cover
  • Glossy paper
  • Pictures and illustrations in color
  • Come in many formats, often slick and attractive
  • Contain many images and graphics (photographs, drawings, etc)

Audience

  • Scholarly readers, such as professors, researchers and students
  • Non-professionals or general audience

Author

  • Experts, scholars, and researchers
  • Staff writers, generalists

Content

  • Research projects, methodology and theory
  • Articles written by contributing authors
  • Personalities, news, and general interest articles
  • Articles written by staff, may be unsigned

Purpose

  • To report on original research in order to make the information available to the rest of the scholarly world
  • To entertain, promote a viewpoint, or sell a product

Writing Style

  • Formal, scholarly
  • Informal; written for anyone to understand

Accountability

  • Peer review/refereed
  • Bibliographies always present
  • No bibliographies
  • Editorial review

Documentation

  • Always cite sources in the form of footnotes or bibliographies
  • Rarely, if ever, cite resources
  • Information often second or third hand and original source often obscure

Publishers

  • Most are published by professional organizations
  • Published by commercial enterprises or individuals

Examples

  • JAMA: The journal of the American Medical Association
  • Journal of Marriage and the Family 
  • Psychology Today
  • Newsweek
  • Sports Illustrated