The
Sporting World of the Modern South. Edited by Peter B. Miller.
University of Illinois Press, 2002. 400 pages, 22 photographs. $49.95
cloth, $19.95 paper.
The
Sporting World of the Modern South is a collection of 13 essays
that illuminate the South’s role in shaping sport and sport’s role
in shaping the South. Edited by Peter B. Miller, the book uses the
myth and fact of sport as a lens by which to consider the possibility
of a distinct South. Exploring ideas of Southern honor, race, and
gender, the essays present the various levels of continuity and
change found in the South during the 20th century.
Miller separates the volume into three sections. The first, “The
Transformation of Southern Sport: Gender, Class, and Some Meanings
of Modernity,” includes essays by Miller, Robert Gudmestad, Pamela
Dean, and Andrew Doyle. Miller’s essay considers the introduction
of team sport in the South following the Civil War and the ideals
of virtue and honor that developed because of such “strenuous masculinity”(22).
Gudmestad turns his attention to baseball in Virginia during the
1880s and its compatibility with romanticized views of the Lost
Cause. Pamela Dean encounters ideas of gender in considering athletics
at women’s colleges in the South. Concluding the first section,
Andrew Doyle explains the University of Alabama’s football success
as a great source of Southern pride and an example of Southern progressive
growth.
The second section of the book is devoted to sport in the South
during segregation and the role sport played in desegregation. Miller
and Rita Liberti look at sport at historically black colleges. Liberti
considers Bennett College, for women, and Miller focuses on Howard
University. Both essays allow the reader to understand the conflicting
opinions that existed over the worth of athletics on a historically
black college campus. In Bennett College’s case, leaders questioned
the role sport should play in a women’s collegiate experience.
The final three essays of section two center on the role of sports
in desegregating society. Charles H. Martin, Jack E. Davis, and
Russell J. Henderson all use various sporting events to show how
the walls of segregation were slowly crumbling. Martin looks at
the Southern traditions of college football bowl games and their
desegregation. Davis chooses baseball’s spring training for his
venue. Henderson explores the Mississippi State University basketball
team’s narrow escape to the national tournament and the state of
Mississippi’s subsequent escape from the “unwritten law”(219). Each
of the previous three essays displays the importance of sport in
the Southern society. While the Sugar Bowl, spring training sights,
and the state of Mississippi did not desegregate as quickly as many
hoped, the importance of sport in the minds, and perhaps pocketbooks,
of Southern organizers allowed previous racial taboos to be broken.
The final section of the book includes four essays that consider
the way Southern stereotypes are portrayed in sport. Andrew Doyle
returns to the subject of Alabama football, but in this essay the
University’s legendary coach Paul Bryant is the center of discussion.
Doyle paints Bryant as the symbol of a South caught between the
love of tradition and the need for progress. His public praise of
the small town, hard working, well-raised Southern young man endeared
him to the mothers and fathers of the region. However, his success
as a business man pointed to the economic needs and potential of
a progressive south. Doyle concludes his essay with a discussion
of the desegregation of Bryant’s Alabama football team, and questions
what might have happened had the most powerful coach in the South
taken a more proactive role.
Following the essay on the powerful sport of football are two intriguing
essays on events exploding in popularity. Louis M. Kyriakoudes and
Peter A Coclanis look at the phenomenal growth of the professional
wrestling’s “sports entertainment” industry. Wove throughout the
world of professional wrestling, positive and negative Southern
stereotypes continue to entertain crowds across the world. Karyn
Charles Rybacki and Donald Jay Rybacki discuss the origins and growth
of NASCAR. The Rybackis explore NASCAR’s ties to Southern myth and
chivalry and contrast such a reputation with the attempt to make
the sport part of mainstream America.
Ted
Ownby’s essay “Manhood, Memory, and White Men’s Sports in the American
South” concludes the book. With the exception of hunting, Ownby
finds sports not to be a part of early 20th-century writers’ definition
of the distinct South. He then considers the popularity of modern
hunting, college football, and stock car racing and searches for
ties to five components of traditional Southern manhood.
Ownby’s work concludes Miller’s collection of various essays that
consider the past role of sport in Southern distinctiveness and
push historians to consider more heavily the role that sport continues
to play. The essays include some, and open the opportunity for more,
study on the fans that attend the sports and the way sport is sold
to those fans. The far-reaching influence of the Olympic Games might
also entice scholars desiring to study the South and sport. Miller’s
collection of essays tackles the South in new and intriguing ways,
and creates intrigue for similar studies in the future.
J. R. Duke