

A
Portion of the People: Three Hundred Years
of Southern Jewish Life. Edited
by Theodore Rosengarten and Dale Rosengarten.
Columbia: University of South Carolina Press,
2002. 288 pages, 86
color plates, 74 halftones. $34.95 cloth.
Through a series of
brief, informative chapters accompanied by
photographs of artifacts, the Rosengartens
introduce readers to
the broad scope of Jewish experience in the
South. Topics include
the immigration experience, home and family
life, the working
lives of men and women, courting and marital
rituals, the
rise of communities, Jewish men and women’s
involvement in
the Civil War, their participation in World War
I, and the post-Holocaust
Southern Jewish experience. Allowing material
culture to
reveal historical experience, the collection of
artifacts that
Dale Rosengarten and others have uncovered
beautifully underscores
the rich complexity of the South Carolina Jewish
experience.
Creating a companion to
such a broad exhibit would have been
plenty, yet the Rosengartens include a marvelous
photo essay
by Bill Aron that surveys contemporary
Southern and Jewish identities.
Included are images that are both
familiar and remarkable. Pictures of three
generations of Southern Jewish hunters,
a Jewish-owned pigeon plant, and African
American Jews are fascinating (though
not surprising, as they testify to successful
Jewish and Southern acculturation).
Other of Aron’s photographs
show synagogues, cemeteries, holiday
meal preparation, prayer, a Mah-jongg game,
and family activities.
In addition to the
photo essay, the Rosengartens
include essays by prominent Jewish
scholars that further illuminate the Southern
Jewish experience. In his preface, Eli
Evans provides a brief history of Jews in
South Carolina, while Theodore Rosengarten
confronts the difficult and complex
relationship of Jews and enslaved African
Americans, agreeing with scholar Bertram
Wallace Korn that Jews observed the
"dominant morality of the time"(4).
The
remaining essays, by Deborah Dash Moore,
Jenna Weissman Joselit, and Jack Bass,
focus on the theme of freedom.
Deborah Dash Moore’s
essay explores the
Americanization of Orthodox Judaism—specifically
how Southern Jews revamped
their Judaism in response to reigning
political, social, and economic systems
and ideologies. Moore situates changes
in American Judaism squarely within
the events of the time and, in particular,
within Denmark Vesey’s slave Jews
saw their place in Southern society as increasingly
unstable and therefore shaped Reform
Judaism to mirror acceptable Christian
customs to secure their own place
and freedom in Southern society. Jenna
Weisman Joselit’s essay addresses the
migration of Jews from Eastern Europe, concentrating
on their reasons for choosing
a virtual frontier over the established
cities of the northeast. The essay
shows that Eastern European immigrants
had different experiences from their
predecessors, working as peddlers, shopkeepers,
and scrap-metal dealers instead
of inserting themselves into the
plantation economy. Joselit also demonstrates
the splits that developed between
earlier and later Jewish migrations and
how they impacted South CarolinaJewry.
Jack
Bass, a native South Carolinian, explores
Jewish participation in civic life throughout
the state’s history, noting that Jews
had been prominently involved in public
and private organizations from the colony’s
inception. Bass juxtaposes Jewish participation
in public life with existent anti-Semitism
in the state and reveals that in
their response to civil rights Southern Jews
both accommodated and subverted Jim
Crow in public and private acts.
Theodore
Rosengarten claims that the exhibition
and the accompanying book are to
dispel myths about Southern Jews. As editors,
Dale and Theodore Rosengarten have
accomplished much more. They have introduced
Jews and non-Jews alike to a vibrant
Southern Jewish culture. Topics, issues,
and the Jewish histories and identities
uncovered and addressed by scholars
and amassed material artifacts are by
no means comprehensive nor are they
meant to be. This book introduces readers
and exhibition viewers to Southern Jewish
history, illuminates the Southern Jewish
experience, and inspires further investigation.
JENNIFER A. STOLLMAN